top of page

High Street Insurance Partners Acquires Donnelly & Sproul, Inc.
Sica | Fletcher advises Donnelly & Sproul, Inc. in its sale to High Street Insurance Partners


Overview of Transaction


  • Initially founded in 1927, Donnelly is a generalist retail P&C agency that has been
    serving the New Jersey community and surrounding states for nearly 100 years with
    business and personal insurance products and services.

  • Donnelly agreed to partner with High Street Insurance Partners (HSIP), a Top 100
    National Insurance Broker headquartered in Traverse City, Michigan.


Significance of Transaction

  • The acquisition provides High Street with a strong agency with an extensive local
    reputation, exceptional experience, and a skilled team of insurance professionals.

  • The acquisition will allow Donnelly to hit the ground running and further expand its
    local presence. High Street’s resources and expertise will allow for immediate, rapid
    expansion, both locally and nationally.


Sica | Fletcher's Role

  • Sica | Fletcher served as exclusive strategic and financial advisor to Donnelly.

  • This transaction highlights the strength of Sica | Fletcher’s relationships with its
    clients and with top-tier investors.

bottom of page