top of page

Sica | Fletcher advises Flagler Insurance Agency, Inc. in its sale to High Street Insurance Partners.

Flagler Tombstone.png

Overview of Transaction

  • Originally founded in 1992, Flagler is a retail Property & Casualty (P&C) insurance agency headquartered in Palm Beach, Florida.

  • Flagler, an established company with three offices located in high-growth markets across Florida, is led by agency president Tyler Schapiro. The agency specializes in providing insurance solutions for the equestrian, commercial real estate, and financial services industries.

  • Flagler agreed to partner with High Street Insurance Partners (HSIP), one of the fastest-growing insurance agencies in North America and a Top 100 National Insurance Broker headquartered in Traverse City, Michigan.

Significance of Transaction

  • This acquisition further reinforces HSIP’s retail presence in the Florida market and leverages Flagler’s specialty expertise within the commercial, personal, and private client insurance services. 

  • The acquisition provides Flagler with the unique opportunity to supercharge growth initiatives with the backing of one of the industry’s top leaders and their robust resources.

Sica | Fletcher's Role

  • Sica | Fletcher served as exclusive strategic and financial advisor to Flagler. 

  • This transaction highlights the strength of Sica | Fletcher’s relationships with leading agencies and top-tier investors.

Logo-Final (1).png
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Youtube

    SITEMAP  |  PRIVACY

Useful Links

All Content Copyright 2025 - Sica | Fletcher LLC | 250 West Street, Suite J | New York, NY 10013

Any information provided herein is indicative only, subject to change, and does not constitute an offer to purchase or sell any financial product. Sica | Fletcher LLC does not underwrite securities, nor advise on, nor effect transactions in securities for the account of others.

bottom of page